About a year ago, I had a rare opportunity to pitch PerksBar to a top level HR executive at a jumbo-sized organization. It was a 1-on-1 meeting where I could walk him through our vision in detail. We shook hands, made small talk, got comfortable, and then I kicked off the pitch: what PerksBar does as employee engagement software, what PerksBar could do for them, how it helps drive culture, and so on. Five minutes in, he paused me: “Wait a minute, how do you actually do employee engagement?”
I replied, “so we engage people through recognition, rewards, challenges, campaigns, and gamification, etc.”
He went, “Oh, so you do gamification. Do you have engagement survey features? How do you measure engagement?”
At that moment, I realized we were circling around and we were talking past each other. When I started the pitch with “employee engagement”, his brain started wiring him to think about surveys, collecting feedback, analyzing the heatmap and the gap, and how to increase the scores. In his mind, he was using the word engagement as a measurement metric, it was a noun and an end result. On the other hand, I was thinking of the word “engage”, it is a verb. To engage people, you do something active; you don't just measure them.
Measuring a Problem Isn’t the Same as Solving It
Over the past couple of years, HR trends have started to shift for the better. But before recently, almost every HR leader I spoke with equated employee engagement with running annual surveys or using fancy terms like "sentiment listening”. Many times, when I spoke to HR about employee engagement, they brought up names like Gallup Q12 or Qualtrics and ask if we were similar. It was as if, in their minds, doing employee engagement equals to hiring Gallup. You might start noticing the problem - we can name drop different big consulting firms, all of them help you “measure” the engagement level, give advice, yet almost none of them “fix” the problem. Why? Because human problems are not easy to resolve, but measuring them gives you an illusion of control.
This disconnect has baffled me for a long time. Engagement is not doing more surveys. As a matter of fact, if you ask any marketing people, what customer engagement is, their first answer won't be "send them a survey"—they’ll tell you to launch a loyalty program or a community experience.
Granted, many HR leaders now acknowledge that surveys are just the starting point, and that bridging the gap between feedback and action is what actually drives engagement. But do we really need an annual survey to know what employees want? Who doesn’t want flexibility, recognition, or decision-making autonomy? Standard surveys often ask obvious questions that yield predictable answers. And even after you fill the gap found from the survey, it doesn’t mean you have finished the engagement task. Because it is a continuous job.
Why do companies treat customers and employees so differently—using rewards, gamification, and delight for customers, while relying on basic survival, stress management, and output metrics for employees?
Treating Employees Like VIP Customers
Let’s put on our marketer hats. If we want to engage customers, we run reward programs. You already have an inner circle of 1,000 employees—they are your ultimate VIP members. How do we engage them? Build an earn-and-burn reward mechanism, run interactive campaigns, strengthen peer connections, and continuously reinforce company values through lived culture. When new VIPs onboard, give them a seamless experience. Use targeted, lightweight pulse surveys—the way Duolingo asks users how they feel—to keep a pulse on real-time sentiment.
Surveys and heatmaps are valuable tools for course correction. But we need to stop treating the measurement tool as the engagement strategy itself. It’s time to start actually engaging your people like a marketer.
In my next article, I will challenge another commonly and widely accepted engagement concept: Wellness is not engagement.